What Not to Wear

I bought a new dress... and I'm gonna wear it Sunday. I need your opinion. I have two jackets/sweaters (whatever you want to call it) and I need to know which one you think looks best.

Here is the dress -


Jacket choice 1 -


Jacket choice 2 -


So which one do you like best? I asked all of my siblings that are at home and well, I won't tell you what they said until you give your opinion!